Killing someone seems perfectly reasonable for young indians. Why?
RAHUL PANDITA | Issue Dated: January 14, 2007
Tags :
|

It is unlikely that Pappu Upadhyaya
would have ever heard the above
lines. But today, nobody would be
a more fi rm believer in these lines
than him. Aft er all, a man, who Pappu
had always thought of as an angel, has
turned out to be India’s most infamous
evil man. It couldn’t have been more
ironical that Pappu, a local panwallah
in Noida, would hear about the evil
deeds of Moninder Singh Pandher on
the television set gift ed to him by none
other than Pandher himself.
Pappu will, perhaps, never come to
terms with what he heard on the television.
But a truth, which is almost worldknown
now, would not care about the
sentiments of a shopkeeper. And yet, it
is hard to believe that someone, who
studied at the country’s premier educational
institutes, and, who, according
to his relatives, had even cleared
the Civil Services examination, would
kill young children, have sex with their
corpses and then dump them in a drain
aft er cutting them into pieces.
As the police continue to fi sh out
bones of hapless victims of Noida
businessman Pandher and his aide
Surendra, there are many skeletons that
are waiting to tumble out of cupboards
– both literal and proverbial. With the
police further probing into the Noida
skeleton case, it is becoming clear that
there is much more to case than what
meets the eye. What prompts people like
Pandher to commit such ghastly acts?
Would it be right to categorise it just
as a case of a killer psychopath preying
on his victims? Or is there something
missing from the picture?

Yes, say psychologists and social
scientists. Th ey blame what they term
as turbo-consumerism for such cases,
especially those involving teenagers. As
India wakes up to easy money, many
believe that unbridled materialistic
desire coupled with numerous
peekaboos into the new world are
leading people to crime. It is as if India
has slipped into a warp, which would
require more Freudian skills than those
of Swami Ramdev to be understood.
It was for purchasing a mobile phone
and celebrating New Year that led three
Chennai juveniles to kidnap and kill 11-
year-old Aravind. Th e three teenagers
befriended Aravind while playing
cricket in their locality and later decided
to kidnap him for ransom money. As
he was being led to their hideout, the
boy started crying. When he could not
be silenced, the trio hit him repeatedly
with a brick and then gagged him till he
lay motionless. Inspired by a scene from
a fi lm, the three teenagers had sprinkled
chilli powder near the scene of crime to
fool the sniff er dogs.
“Th is is very much a part of the new culture,” says psychologist Neelima
Pandey. “Th e old Indian value system
is fast eroding. Insecurity and need for
more money has created gaping holes
in our moral fabric and this is just the
beginning,” Pandey says, while referring
to the Chennai case.
So, what is really happening?
According to sociologists, this: More
and more members of society in urban
and semi-urban areas are getting
exposed to a virtual world created by
television, cinema and Internet. Th is is
the best world where megapixel mobile
phones have replaced notebooks.
Instead of U-special buses, there are
cruise bikes. College canteen is passé.
It has to be cafes and lounges, and it
is. It is a world where diamonds are a
girl’s best friend; where
she no longer thinks that
a greeting card would
suffi ce. Belonging to this
world is the ‘in thing.’
It would almost seem,
sociologists say, as if not
belonging to this world
means one has no right
to exist.
“Th ere is a sense of
adventurism among
young people. Due to hectic schedules
of parents, there is a passive negligence
of children, more so in metros like
Delhi. Th ey are exposed to uncensored
images that inspire them to experiment.
Th ey think that money can give them
the required high, which leads some of
them to crime,” says Dr. Sandeep Vohra,
a noted psychiatrist.
A 15-year-old boy from Lucknow
recently faked his own kidnapping
because he wanted money to buy a
mobile phone. Sachin had been feeling
embarrassed about every one in his
school possessing a mobile phone
except him. He had his eyes set upon a
Nokia handset costing Rs 30,000. One
day, aft er he left home for school, he
decided not to come back. Instead, he
called his home, using the hanky-overthe-
mouthpiece technique, and made
the demand for money to his father.
He was caught from Kanpur, aft er the
police tracked down the number. He
later told the police that his friends in
the school had latest motorcycles and
mobiles and that he was embarrassed
in front of the girls.
Th e silver lining in Sachin’s case was
that at least he set up a ruse for his
own kidnapping. Otherwise, in most
of such cases, the target happens to
be young children.
Experts believe that
children become
targets because
they can be easily
overpowered either
for money or sexual
gratifi cation. Th is
view is corroborated
by statistics from
the National Crime
Records Bureau
(NCRB). According to the NCRB, there
has been a 3.8% increase in criminal
cases against children in 2005, as
compared to 2004. Th e cases of child
rape marked an alarming increase
of 13.7% in 2005 as compared to the
3,542 cases in 2004. “We are facing the
onslaught of fast age – fast food, fast
fame and success. Parents are caught
in a rat race and the children have to
only follow them. But it comes at a cost
and that cost is, at times, mental health,”
says Dr. Vohra.
What may be diff erent in Pandher’s
case, experts say, is that he thought
since he has money, he will get away
with anything. What is worrying is
that more and more youngsters seem
to believe that if they have money,
they will get away with anything. And
to get that money, they are willing to
do anything.
The national
capital region:
killer’s delight?
Delhi is surrounded by two
fast growing urban areas,
Gurgaon and Noida, which
have become the new face of
upwardly-mobile India. But
over the past few months,
these areas have also become
synonymous with some
horrifi c crimes. People were
yet to come to terms with
the Gurgaon cab killers when
skeletons came tumbling
out of Noida. It was just two
months ago when a gang of
seven men was arrested who
had killed 35 people since
last January in and around
Gurgaon. The killers usually
targeted innocent people
seeking lift at night and then
strangled them to loot their
personal valuables.
In the past, Delhi has been
trying to contain increasing
cases of crime, especially
against women, with some
even dubbing the city as the
‘rape capital’ of India.