An IIPM Initiative
Tuesday, January 31, 2023

Courts for the rich Amar Singh and Abhishek Manu Singhvi. Who for poor Pinki?


ARINDAM CHAUDHURI | New Delhi, July 12, 2012 15:45
Tags : pinki pramanik | gender determination test | abhishek manu singhvi sex scandal | amar singh |

It is inhuman! It is outrageous! And it is disgusting! The manner is which Pinki Pramanik, a national athlete who brought laurels for the nation at various international sporting events, is being sullied by all and sundry. Thanks to media, today she has become a household name, more infamous due to the controversy on her gender, than due to the gold medals she won at the Asian and Commonwealth Games. Pinki’s sporting achievements include a team relay gold medal at the 2006 Asian Games, another gold at the 2005 Asian Indoor Games, silver medal in the 2006 Commonwealth Games, beside many other medals at national and international levels.

It is no secret that Pinki was recently charged of raping a woman – who was also her live-in partner – as it has been alleged that Pinki has both male and female reproductive organs. However, that is yet to be proved, as she is being forced into medical tests one after the other with inconclusive results. The moot point here is not with respect to her gender, but the shocking manner in which the Indian media has been treating an internationally acclaimed athlete. The media has left no stone unturned to publicly strip her dignity, by repeatedly focusing on her gender determination issue and by indiscriminately telecasting her semi-nude to nude videos. The authorities too have been sniping at her. The glaring example being a male policeman physically accosting her, as he might have accosted a male criminal, even before Pinki’s gender has been determined. And this was done in full public glare and with media’s presence.

Meanwhile, the media seems to be hyper active by not only going into the very personal life of Pinki, but also by airing obscene clips, completely destroying her private life. Worse, she was shown totally naked and a video of her undergoing medical tests at a nursing home in West Bengal was also aired all over! This MMS had been circulated through the internet and is widely available. And unfortunately, there’s no one to stop this national auction of the dignity of someone who has brought national pride through her talent!

So would the case have been different had her background been different? It doesn’t require a genius to establish the fact that what Pinki is going through is just because she hails from a poor background and doesn’t have influential lobbies behind her. Here, I would like to bring in the case of Amar Singh and Abhishek Singhvi. Tapes apparently related to them that were being circulated over the net were removed instantly; even the courts came to their rescue. In Amar Singh’s case, it was claimed that he had had some conversations with Bollywood stars in 2006, wherein he allegedly offered to change government policies to suit vested interests. Post the leak, Amar Singh filed a petition in the apex court and got the airing of his tapes stopped from the media. In another case earlier this year, the sex tape purportedly featuring Abhishek Manu Singhvi was barred from being aired in public domain. The Delhi High Court’s ex parte order instructed media houses and restrained them from airing footage from any such tapes related to Singhvi. For the uninitiated, Abhishek Singhvi was no common man, but a politician belonging to INC and a member of the Rajya Sabha and had been the spokesperson of the Congress party too! In both these cases, bans on airing these tapes were imposed before anything could have been proved. Like Pinki’s case, no concrete and final conclusions were reached, nor were the allegations proved. But such bans on transmitting objectionable material at least could save Pinki and the likes from mass embarrassment.

But in the case of Pinki, the print as well as the electronic media did not leave any stone unturned. Even her medical test videos were made available all across the internet and spread like viruses over cell phones too! Misleading reports with headlines like, “Pramanik bribed officials to hide her gender,” or “Athlete sent to jail for rape” are being circulated all over the internet. Even leading dailies have not been sympathetic to her. One derogatory headline in one of the leading dailies read as, “After questions on gender, Pinki Pramanik now faces MMS ordeal.” Out came two more headlines in one of the recognized national dailies: “Athlete Pinki Pramanik arrested on “rape” charges” and “Pinki has male features”. Is there any point accusing her of rape or declaring her gender as male, when nothing has been proven yet?

We all know how our establishment works (devoid of any compassion and consideration) but the beleaguered person can at least expect some humane treatment from our so-called “free press”! But sadly, that’s missing too, to say the least. Media should have at least shown some discretion by protecting the identity of the person due to the sensitivity involved, instead of sensationalizing the issue, irrespective of the fact that the individual in question is an international athlete. It was also divulged in the media (and wrongly so) that the initial tests conducted at a private hospital revealed that Pinki was a male! Such reporting is malicious, irresponsible and totally a TRP grabbing exercise – and must be condemned by the responsible sections of the media and judiciary immediately.

Indeed, in the name of gender tests, Pinki is being shifted to different hospitals, which itself is detrimental to her mental and physical wellbeing. As if this was not enough, Pinki was even kept in the male ward at Presidency Jail in Kolkata. Further, she lost her job with Indian Railways! The hounding media featured every intricate detail of the Pinki’s sexual relationship with her partner. They showed how she enjoyed a sensual life and at the same time also showed her partner painting her as a rapist.

This is not just a clear case of defamation of Pinki, but also shows how courts come to the rescue of only those who wield power and money to influence the system. A simple Google search would reveal how hundreds of girls/women have had their obscene videos spread all across – from them being stripped publicly to being molested in public! Still, courts have not ordered the local authorities to remove these shameful videos and objectionable material! The Supreme Court should immediately order all media houses to remove not only Pinki’s but all other similarly objectionable content from the net and even from their archives. This is the least we can do as a nation, to reverse the social stigma individuals like Pinki have gone through!

Rate this article:
Bad Good    
Current Rating 4.7
Post CommentsPost Comments
Posted By: Ajit | Jalandhar | August 7th 2012 | 18:08
This is awful and shame to nation's law, bureaucracy and media which sensationalized such a sensitive issue dealing with a international acclaimed athlete and auctioned her dignity in air without a second thought. In a country which has a second largest population, we beg for a single medal and this is how we treat our achievers. The volume of such incidents only deters trust of someone on justice, media and law. Social responsibility and morality seems to have vanished from our soul and only left to adore the books of kindergarten.
Posted By: P V Ariel | Secunderabad | July 19th 2012 | 15:07
What a shameful treatment to an internationally acclaimed sports personality by our politicians/courts and the so called authorities. Though she achieved many laurels to the country the leaders of this nation is simply neglected her plea and plight, instead they harassed her shamelessly and shifted to different hospitals in the name of gender tests. This is indeed a shameful act from the part of the authorities. At the same time it’s not a surprising thing that the rich and powerful can always escape from their dirty acts with their muscle power and money, that is what happened in the case of two mighty personalities (politicians) mentioned in the editorial. The same is repeated all over India. Though the media (print and visual) in India is always after such stories to increase their TRP rates, TSI showed an excellent example to the media by questioning the acts of the mighty, the court and the politicians. TSI’s counterparts in India should adapt one or two leaves from TSI’s book. I appreciate Prof. Arindam Chowdary and his team for the fearless and truthful writings, especially to reveal the misdeeds of our mighty politicians. May such tribes increase; we (India) need more such mighty and powerful press to bring out such anomalies prevailing in our system. Let the press in India stand for the well being of the poor and needy.

Issue Dated: Feb 5, 2017