Special Report... Read More
  User ID  Password   New User?  Sign Up Now!
    Welcome  Guest
       Search
T  H  E           S  U  N  D  A  Y          I  N  D  I  A  N
Other Sections
 
Musings
Print this story Email story to friend Single page view Comment on story
Prasoon-S-Majumdar

Prasoon S. Majumdar
Editor, Economic Affairs
The Sunday Indian

It was not just the gas!
The gas was the beginning of the Bhopal tragedy...
 
Though it has been a considerable time, but the memories of that fateful night never seem to end. I was in Bhopal during that time and overnight an otherwise non-significant city shot to significance – albeit for all wrong reasons. I’m referring to one of the biggest industrial disasters in recorded history that killed more than 15,000 lives, caused permanent sight and respiratory damages to millions, orphaned children in thousands and effected an entire generation in some way or the other. Though quarter of a century has passed away since the disaster rocked the city, but even today the reminiscent of the same still echoes in each and every corner of the city. In fact, Bhopal gas tragedy never ended, it just started on the fateful night of December 2 and 3 in 1984, when methyl isocyanate (MIC) gas and other toxins leaked from the Union Carbide factory in Bhopal, eventually claiming more than 15,000 lives and affecting 5,74,000 people till date. And ever since then, the tragedy of these people continue, perpetually...

Once the tragedy occurred, Bhopal looked like a mortuary overnight. There were just corpses and corpses all around! For those who managed to survive the MIC - inadequate health infrastructure and lack of doctors and medicines killed them. And for those who survived that too, the compensation (lack of it) killed them. In fact post the tragedy, which was discovered to be more of a human error, the government bargained a full and final compensation of $470 million. In fact so much has been written on this compensation amount - that the volume of the poisonous gas that leaked that fateful night would fall short of the volumes that have been written on the same. It is no secret that everyone advocated that $470 million was too little a compensation for the kind of tragedy that it was. Honestly, for any tragedy, and that too of the scale of Bhopal, any amount of compensation would fall short. There is no doubt that Union Carbide brutally short changed the victims of its own gas. So for those who survived to hear about the compensation, died before they actually got it, on account of perennial delay! And for those who managed to survive the delay, could not survive the fact that by the time they actually got the compensation it was reduced to a fifth of what they were entitled to, as the number of affected people raised by five folds. Which meant that the amount which was to be initially distributed amongst a lac people was now to be distributed to five lacs! And for those who survived the hope for this meager compensation, the racketeers killed them. The compensation amount created lot of racketeers who siphoned of the compensation by creating ghost victims. These rackets are still active in Bhopal. In fact an entire ghost economy runs within Bhopal, which is based out of compensation amount. And I’m sure that for those who had the tenacity to endure everything, starting from MIC to the racketeers – this news is going to definitely kill them. To commemorate the 25th year of the tragedy, the relief and rehabilitation minister Babulal Gaur has asked for Rs116 crore from the Centre to develop “a memorial of international standard - akin to the one in Hiroshima, Japan, depicting a detailed account of the world's worst industrial disaster”.

On the face of it, sounds to be a nice thought, but then to create a memorial for an ongoing tragedy is kind of tragic in itself! And at a cost which is a seventh of that of the entire compensation, is kind of obscene!

No wonder the Bhopal gas tragedy continues…
 
          
 


       Comments   
   
      
JAIDEEP CHATTERJEE From DURGAPORE--
12/29/2009
MR.PRASOON S.MAJUMDAR, YES I DO AGREE WITH YOU,THAT BESIDES THE GAS,THERE IS POWER POSITION PLAY AND PROGRAM OF ANDERSON WHO MADE IT POSSIBLE TO BE REALITIES,AN AMERICAN ALWAYS TREAT THE MASSES OF THIRD WORLD NOT MORE THAN A MERE COMMUDITY AND THAT IS WHY IN INDIA,THERE ARE MORE THAN THOUSAND US BASED DRUG MANUFACTURES ARE DEEPLY ENGAGED IN SELLING AS MANY AS 83000 DIFFERENT KINDS OF MEDICINES,BY INVOLVING RATHER IN COLLUSION WITH MINISTERIAL AUTHORITIES,YEAR AFTER YEAR,WHERE AS EVERY INDIANS NEED NOT MORE THAN 23000 MEDICINES TO CHECK EVERY POSSIBLE AND AVAILABLE DISEASES PREVAILED AROUN THE COUNTRY...

   


     Leave Comments to this story    
     
Name:  
Comments:  
Email id:  
City:  
 
 
 
 
Other Stories
 • It was not just the gas!
Ho Chi Minh to M. Albert Sarraut
The UN copenhagen conference is an opportunity for developing countries like India and China to set their own standards and work towards the creation of a better and cleaner world!
Bonding vs Rich bonding...
Apocalypse!!!
Foreign Affairs - Turkey’s new policy worries EU
Unification heroes or headless chickens?
Assam protests Arunachal plans
Lord Jagannath Getting Richer
No smooth run for Presidency
Has the aura faded?
The night that never ended
‘National pride rides on 2010 Delhi Games’
125 years call for a grand party!
So, who moves the cheese?
Global warming: An inconvenient truth or a convenient untruth?
We’ve turned Earth’s thermostat up…
All smoke (and mirrors), no fire
Climate Science is Sound...
Global warming: Beliefs versus science
What’s age gotta do with it?!
A lost treasure
Bringing up father
Wind from the woods
Indira Gandhi - Remembering ‘madam’
Read Commented Stories
Our own banana republics!
Our MPs always have a Consensus on Personal Gains and Differences on National Imperatives!
Brewing trouble - Parties, media to blame
Peepli Live-Satire and sensibility
63 years and bonded labour...
Housewives are an invaluable unpaid resource and def initely not unproductive!
Justic Uninterrupted
Service providers or rent seekers?!
Be like the lotus…
Kerala IT: An early riser but a slow runner
A Pakistani in America - VII
Napoleon to Josephine
‘General’ atrophy
The lotus wilts
In the insurance imbroglio, the common man is the scapegoat again!
'I’ve been a target since 1992'
A Date with farming
Physical punishment in schools leading to deaths and suicides… are we fit to be teachers?
Higher education - Look beyond set options
Autumn of the DONS

 
   The Sunday Indian ( India's Greatest News Magazine) is also associated with :
©Copyright 2008, Planman Media Pvt. Ltd. An Arindam Chaudhuri Initiative. With Intellectual Support from IIPM & Malay Chaudhuri.