Special Report... Read More
  User ID  Password   New User?  Sign Up Now!
    Welcome  Guest
       Search
T  H  E           S  U  N  D  A  Y          I  N  D  I  A  N
Other Sections
 
Cover Feature
Print this story Email story to friend Single page view Comment on story
THE STATE HAS WITHERED AWAY
State-less in west bengal
The Marxists have dissolved their own governance, says T. Bhattacharya
 
How many deaths will it take till he knows that too many people have died? The answer, for once, is not blowing in the wind. This bout of pessimism stems from a figure close to 300 – the number of political killings in West Bengal since parliamentary elections were held this year. The last cases reported were from Khanakul in Hoogly district and Sashan in North 24 Parganas.

In fresh clashes in Nanoor in Birbhum district on November 3, where armed cadres of CPI(M) clashed with villagers in their bid to seize lost political control, scores of houses have been torched and at least 22 persons grievously injured. On November 4, while this magazine was going to the press, there were reports of fresh violence from Arambagh area of Hoogly. This culture of violence that has engulfed the state is unfortunately the contribution of the largest constituent of the Left Front state government, the CPI(M). Used to overarching hegemony for close to 32 years, during which the CPI(M) penetrated nearly every professional class and every sphere of people’s lives, the party simply can’t come to terms with the electoral reverses in this year’s polls. And like in the case of Singur and Nandigram, armed cadres are busy doling out retributive ‘justice’ to people who did not vote for the party. If the bullets of Nandigram had their effect on the Lok Sabha ballot boxes, the forecast for the 2011 Assembly elections is abundantly clear. The party, for the first time, is afraid of political disappearance from the state. The irony is that by sticking to desperate use of brute force, it is making a reappearance bid all the more difficult. The party satraps at AK Gopalan Bhavan may dabble in dialectics to substantiate the Marxist-Leninist character of the party but the cadres have taken to Mao. In the villages of West Bengal, CPI(M)’s ‘power comes from the barrel of the gun’.

For 32 years, the party had reaped benefits from politicising the state administrative apparatus down to the village level. But now, things have turned turtle. The administration is slipping wherever the party is losing ground. This has made the Maoists’ task easier. The CPI(M) party workers in Junglemahal (Bengal-Jharkhand-Orissa border) are today scared to carry out political activity. Resultantly, the administration has ceased to exist except in certain pockets.

Effectively, the region north of Siliguri town, i.e the Darjeeling Hills is not governed by the state government. The Gorkha Janamukti Morcha controls nearly all aspects of political governance there.

The most dangerous moment of an arbitrary system arrives when it tries to reform itself. And when it even fails to acknowledge the need for reforms and, instead, forces itself upon people, it withers away. West Bengal is a classic example in point - the State-less state of the State of India. Karl Marx had laid down the philosophical principles for withering away of the state. Marxists in Bengal have realised it in practice.

 
          
 


       Comments   
   
      
Leave your first comment

   


     Leave Comments to this story    
     
Name:  
Comments:  
Email id:  
City:  
 
 
 
 
Other Stories
 • State-less in west bengal
 • Use of force a cardinal mistake
 • “Government exists but only as a tool of oppression’’
 • Delhi set to charge the maoist Red rag
 • “Trinamool trying to fish in troubled waters’’
Lajpat Rai to Syed Ahmad Khan
Mamta’s life is not safe…
Because in these elections, nothing else can prevent the inevitable from happening!

The Sun sets in the east
From pro-power to pro-poor
More Fireworks!!!
Obama -Reading between the lines
Eastern Promises
Farmers left in the lurch
Sunderbans calling
Chicken scam busted
Telecom Tellall
Inside fortress Lanka
Food for thought
A quiet celebration…
11 Cheers for the Osian's-Cinefan film festival!
Funny Irani
‘‘Extremism precedes terrorism’’
Africa Diary III: Kiboko! Kiboko!!
All effects, no magic!
Dreams gone sour
Wind from the woods
War & peace - The state vs the Maoists
Read Commented Stories
Our own banana republics!
Our MPs always have a Consensus on Personal Gains and Differences on National Imperatives!
Brewing trouble - Parties, media to blame
Peepli Live-Satire and sensibility
63 years and bonded labour...
Housewives are an invaluable unpaid resource and def initely not unproductive!
Justic Uninterrupted
Service providers or rent seekers?!
Be like the lotus…
Kerala IT: An early riser but a slow runner
A Pakistani in America - VII
Napoleon to Josephine
‘General’ atrophy
The lotus wilts
In the insurance imbroglio, the common man is the scapegoat again!
'I’ve been a target since 1992'
A Date with farming
Physical punishment in schools leading to deaths and suicides… are we fit to be teachers?
Higher education - Look beyond set options
Autumn of the DONS

 
   The Sunday Indian ( India's Greatest News Magazine) is also associated with :
©Copyright 2008, Planman Media Pvt. Ltd. An Arindam Chaudhuri Initiative. With Intellectual Support from IIPM & Malay Chaudhuri.